Waterloo Columbus Sailors take Wind out of Tiger Sails

November 21, 2004
by Helen D. Gunderson, Gazette editor
printer friendly version — text only

Many people have called the 2004 Gilbert Tiger football season awesome, if not miraculous, perhaps even a Cinderella story. However, the headline story on the sports page of the Ames Tribune on Saturday says the Tigers are tired of wearing the Cinderella tag. They believe that they have proven they are for real.


Tiger tailback Brian Schmidt on run

Regardless of how the players or coaches view the Cinderella label, their program has gone through a delightful turnaround. Their success has excited many people — diehard fans and lots of other folk who have gotten caught up in Tiger fever and the team’s mantra, "Believe."
It’s hard to know what words to use except the ones listed above that have been said over and over, even if they don’t adequately describe the perspectives of the people inside the program. And to say that a season is awesome, miraculous, or like a Cinderella story is not meant to take any credit away from the Gilbert program and the achievements that the coaches and players have made.

Be that as it may, at 1:00 pm on Saturday, the Gilbert football team faced Waterloo Columbus in the Iowa Class 2A Championship Game. The Tigers had not been in the state football play-off series since 1979. They had a 26-109 record in the 15 years prior to the 2004 season and won only four games in the last three years. They went into Saturday's contest with a 10-2 record.

According to the Tribune, the Sailors were a powerhouse football team in the 1980s and won the state championship in 1986. They had a mediocre season a year ago but rallied this year and won three games in a row in October. However, they went into a skid, losing three out of their last four regular season games. But the Sailors, too, had their share of surprises and went on a winning march through post season play. Their record was 9-3 heading into the big game at the Dome. They left the Dome with a 10-3 record and the championship trophy. Their leader, Aundra Meeks, who is graduate of Columbus, is the first African-American coach to win an Iowa high school football championship game.

Fox Television Network televised the game. During the pre-game show, the commentator talked about how Waterloo Columbus has a great passing game balanced with a good running game. He said, "The Gilbert defense has a tall task today."


Tiger quarterback Dan Clark

Gilbert received the opening kickoff, and Gilbert was indeed a "for real" contender with a chance to take home the championship trophy. The team master-minded a series of 15 rushing and passing plays to move the ball 71 yards.
Unfortunately, with a fourth down and two yards to go, the Columbus defense threw Gilbert fullback Adam Weber for a loss. Then on the Sailors’ opening play, quarterback Brad Schmit completed a pass to split end Ben McMahon, who was running a post pattern, for 84 yards and a touchdown. It was the longest touchdown pass play in an Iowa 2A championship game. The Sailors kicked the extra point and took a 7-0 lead.

Waterloo’s big play on defense (i.e. stopping the Tigers on fourth down) and then the big play on offense (the 84-yard touchdown) could have sucked the wind out of any team. However, Gilbert looked as though it would recover, moving the ball 50 yards in nine plays. The series was cut short when the Sailors intercepted a Dan Clark pass. Waterloo then moved the ball 78 yards in 10 plays and upped their lead to 14-0 in the second quarter. There was no more scoring in the first half.

A two-touchdown lead at half-time is no assurance of victory nor does it mean a team is sinking to defeat. On Saturday, the Iowa State Cyclones were down 23-9 against Kansas State but scored three touchdowns in the final three minutes of the game to win with a score of 37-23. As the Des Moines Register said this morning, "Iowa State clinched at least a share of the Big 12 Conference's North Division title — giving the Cyclones their first league crown of any kind since 1912."

There were some positive signs for Gilbert in the first half statistics. The Tigers had 58 yards rushing while the Sailors had eight yards on the ground. The Tigers had 10 first downs while the Sailors had six. And the Tigers had only one penalty for five yards while the Sailors had three for 34 yards. But there were troubling statistics. The Sailors passed for 180 yards while the Tigers passed for 58. And on defense, the Sailors made eight tackles that caused Tiger losses. The Tigers made only one tackle for a loss.


Adam Gregorson chases Sailor QB

Unfortunately, Waterloo Columbus simply increased its momentum in the second half, and it seemed there was little that Gilbert could do. The Sailors scored their final touchdown with 10 minutes left in the game, making the score 41-0. They kicked the ball to Gilbert, who took a touchback and began play on their own 20 yard line.
The Tigers tried to run the ball. On first down, they lost one yard. On second down, they gained nothing. And on third down, they lost another seven yards.

Gilbert Head Coach Scott Auderer called a time out and walked onto the field to huddle with his players. There was fervor in his voice, and a photographer, who was not far from the conversation, said that Auderer told the team words to the effect that he, the rest of the coaching staff, and the players had worked too hard during the season to give up. It would have taken a miracle for the team to overcome the 41 point deficit with only eight minutes and 16 seconds left in the game, but Auderer seemed to be suggesting that the players put some fire in the belly so they could hold their heads high when they went off the field.

An observer has to wonder if, how, and when the mantra "believe" came up in the huddle or other coaching situations on Saturday at the Dome. The mantra is not magic, and it is certainly one of many factors: physical aptitude, conditioning, learning and perfecting plays, good scouting reports, playmaking intelligence, sports psychology, people skills, teamwork, trust, morale, and a bunch of other things, including luck. However, the mantra has been the most heralded factor in the Tiger's turnaround season. It would be a cheap shot to ask if the team forgot its mantra yesterday and lost its essential focus of believing, but it is natural to be curious about what happened.

This whole matter of "believe" as an avenue for wholesome living and success is an intriguing one. It  is something that spiritual leaders, psychotherapists, Twelve Step programs, human resource coordinators, coaches, parents, and many other sages have tried to fathom and facilitate. Life is an eb and flow. To tap into the spark of believing that a person is of intrinsic value and can be successful is hard enough. To maintain contact with that vision 100 percent of the time doesn't seem realistic. Life has its off moments. Besides, Gilbert is probably not the only team that possessed a sense of believing but lost a key game.

Believing is something that carries a person through highs and lows and the plateaus of life. I suppose I could expound further. For instance, I could lament that in my years of majoring in physical education and teaching, I never had a course on sports psychology. Or in my own life's journey, I hunger for the kind of mentoring that it appears the coaching staff has given the players. But I better avoid blathering too much about this whole sphere of thought that fills the shelves of many a library, bookstore, or personal bookshelf.

I only have inklings from what I have observed at games and what I have heard from parents and students about what Coach Auderer means when he talks about the need for the players to believe. I have only a few clues as to how he has worked with athletes to instill a sense of believing in themselves, their peers, and their leaders. Perhaps Coach Auderer could teach a continuing education workshop for the community on Sports Psychology 101. Then again, to think of it, he and his staff and team have already provided a pretty good lesson for those of us who have gotten inspired by the success of the Tiger football season that ended yesterday.

There were no more plays of consequence in the game, and the score stood at 41-0 when the final buzzer sounded. The Gilbert players maintained their composure. Some even turned to the crowd and raised their helmets in the air in an attempt to rally themselves and the Gilbert fans and remember the successes of their season.

OK, OK. The Cinderella metaphor probably isn’t a good one. And it is not wise at this point to talk about a magical spell being broken when the clock strikes midnight and the coach reverts to being a pumpkin and the horses revert to being mice. How about some fable that involves sailors on the high seas who bring their vessel alongside another and clamber aboard, taking control? As the television commentator said after Waterloo’s first touchdown at 4:45 in the first half, the big play on defense followed by the 84-yard touchdown pass was a devastating turn of events for Gilbert. Sports commentators don’t always know what they are talking about, but the one on Fox Television apparently did and had an apt premonition about what would happen. To use the high seas metaphor, the Waterloo Columbus Sailors commandeered the Gilbert ship.

In the final statistics, the Sailors rushed for 295 yards compared to the Tigers who ran for 83 yards. The Sailors passed for 258 yards compared to 60 for the Tigers. And the Sailors made 12 tackles that resulted in lost yards while the Tigers made only one.

On the Saturday evening news on KCCI Channel 8 TV, Coach Auderer said that he would have preferred to play the game anyplace else than the comfortable UNI-Dome, perhaps in rain or snow. He claimed that the Tigers and Sailors simply didn’t match up well. Apparently he thought that inclement weather would have leveled the playing field. For sure, he probably has a lot more to say to his players and staff that he does not want to be broadcasted on the air or printed in the newspapers. And there is a lot of other talk that will go on. There will be discussions in the inner circles among the coaching staff and players. There will be the buzz of fellow students, parents, and the public at large. But it probably will be many, many years before Gilbert is ever called a Cinderella football team again. That should be one consolation to the coaches and players.


score 41-0, Tigers have a 4th and 12 on their 18 yard line, 3:06 left in the game

The Gilbert football staff and players should not need consolations, even though it is understandable that they might have some heartache and grief about being shut out by such a large margin. However, the Tigers left the Dome on Saturday with a 10-3 season record and a second place trophy from the state championship game. In addition, Trevor Schwartz, a senior offensive lineman and linebacker for Gilbert, was presented the Iowa Class 2A award, sponsored by the Grinnell Mutual Reinsurance Company, for being an all-around outstanding student athlete. Members of the Gilbert squad were also selected to the Des Moines Register all-state team. Junior tailback Brian Schmidt is on the first team offense. Junior place kicker Alex Bowers is on the second team offense. And Schwartz is on the second team defense. It seems that Coach Auderer would make a great candidate for the Mid-Iowa Coach of the Year. That designation will most likely be published in the Ames Tribune this week.


IHSAA officials hold top two trophies

That’s plenty of exquisite treasure from the high seas for one year. Next year, the team will set sail again. About a dozen players will graduate, but there will be a good number of young and experienced talent returning to constitute the 2005 crew. As Coach Auderer said in the Ames Tribune on Saturday, "These kids are trying to establish a tradition. They’re not out for one big year and done type of thing."

The wind may have been sucked out of the Tiger sails in the short term, but there is tomorrow. It is a new day. The Gilbert ship is seaworthy, the sails will be trimmed, and there will be new currents of wind when it is time to venture out of the harbor again. Of course, there is the question about who will captain the vessel.

This is Auderer’s first year at the helm. Prior to this season, Chad Cook coached the Tigers for four years. Chad is a military captain, having served in the National Guard for 18 years. Early in 2004, he was called to active military duty in Afghanistan but is currently on a two-week leave that coincides with the birthdays of his young son and daughter. He apparently attended the Tiger games at the UNI-Dome but sat in the stands.

Certainly there will be private and public discussions and speculations about the future of the team’s leadership, considering that the players' morale was high this year and they won 10 games this year under Auderer while losing most of their games under Cook. It’s not an easy dilemma. But there is wisdom in taking one day at a time. Experience the grief of losing. Experience the joy of what went well. Tomorrow is a new day, and 2005 is a new season.

Thanks to the Gilbert coaching staff and players for the excitement they have added to the lives of their followers. It’s been a great voyage. Members of the community near and far will savor the memories. Let the people say, "Hallelujah and Amen."

latest corrections and revisions December 3, 2004

Note: three seniors on the Waterloo Columbus team were selected to the Class 2A first team offensive football squad. They are: end Ben McMahon, quarterback Brad Schmit; and place kicker Nathan Rausa.

Article in the Des Moines Sunday Register. For more coverage of the season, go to the Ames Tribune and use the search tool to look for the word "Gilbert." For official announcements, go to the web site for the Gilbert school district.

Register article about Chad Cook and the Gilbert football program

archived Gazette interview with Chad when he was called to active duty

The Story of Cinderella

Click on any photo above for a larger view.

Photos from the championship game:

01. pre-game coin toss
02. Gilbert offensive lineup
03. Gilbert offensive backfield
04. Gilbert QB Dan Clark passes
05. Tigers up against Sailors' pass machine
06. Sailor quarterback passes
07. Coach Auderer talks to Tigers on field
08. Gilbert sideline crew
09. post game hand-shaking line up
10. Coach Auderer congratulates Trevor Schwartz
11. IHSAA representatives hold top two trophies
12. the Tiger fans

The photo images are by Helen Gunderson, editor of the Gazette. As per the terms of service of this web site, she reserves all rights to the photos. Gazette visitors may reproduce the images for personal use. For further information, contact Helen.

go to Gilbert Gazette home page

    

This page is part of the Gilbert Gazette archives, which consists primarily of documents published prior to July 2, 2006.
  explanation of Gazette archives
main page of archive of Gazette materials
main page of welcome to Gilbert section

"Never doubt that a small group of thoughtful committed people can change the world — indeed it's the only thing that ever has!"     Margaret Mead, American anthropologist

c2002 The Gilbert Gazette Group
contact us
terms of service